The Pros and Cons of Using Artificial Intelligence for Mental Health Self-Help

Artificial intelligence (AI) is revolutionizing many industries, and mental health care is no exception. AI-powered tools are increasingly being used as self-help resources for people struggling with anxiety, depression, stress, and other mental health concerns. While these tools offer accessibility and convenience, they also come with limitations that needs to be accounted for. I was sceptical before trying it, however, I must admit I was pleasantly surprised by the capabilities of AI. It cannot do anything a therapist can do, still, it can do much more then I thought.
In this blog post, I’ll explore the pros and cons of using AI for mental health self-help from my perspective.

Pros of AI in Mental Health Self-Help

1. Accessibility and Affordability

One of the biggest advantages of AI-powered mental health tools is their accessibility. Many people face barriers to traditional therapy, such as high costs, long wait times, or lack of local providers. AI-driven apps provide instant support at a fraction of the cost of in-person therapy, making mental health care more available to a wider audience.
On the other side there is no accountability, if AI is not understanding correctly your situation or your actual state of mind, it can go wrong. For this reason I consider AI more of a coaching tool than a real therapy tool. If you feel fragile and needing professional support, be really careful how you get that help.

2. 24/7 Availability

Unlike human therapists, AI chatbots and apps are available around the clock. This can be especially helpful during moments of crisis when immediate support is needed. For individuals dealing with insomnia, panic attacks, or late-night anxiety, AI tools can offer real-time coping strategies.

3. Anonymity and Reduced Stigma

Some people hesitate to seek therapy due to fear of judgment or stigma. AI provides a private, non-judgmental space where users can express their feelings without fear of embarrassment. This can encourage more people to seek help who might otherwise avoid it.

4. Personalized Recommendations

AI can analyse user input—such as journal entries, mood logs, or chat conversations—to offer tailored suggestions. Machine learning algorithms can detect patterns in behavior and recommend coping mechanisms, mindfulness exercises, or even suggest when professional help might be necessary.

This is also a capability that entails a certain risks of mistake that can be dangerous if you are in a fragile state. When you use AI for mental health you are responsible for what can go wrong: misunderstanding, feeling pressure to do exercises or activity that feel too much too soon.

5. Supplement to Traditional Therapy

AI tools can serve as a useful supplement to traditional therapy by helping users track moods, practice cognitive-behavioral techniques, or reinforce lessons learned in therapy sessions. This continuous support can improve treatment adherence and outcomes.

This is the most interesting aspect of AI related to mental health. Getting support in sticking to a plan like a repetitive activity to foster well-being, or similar activities that are woven in the therapeutic process. It can even help you take charge of your own process in a more complex and empowering way.

Cons of AI in Mental Health Self-Help

1. Lack of Human Empathy

While AI can simulate conversation, it lacks genuine human empathy and emotional understanding. A chatbot might offer scripted responses, but it cannot truly comprehend complex human emotions or provide the deep connection that many people need during difficult times.

Still, I was pleasantly surprise to notice how professional, gentle and extra giving the exchange with AI was. There is no limit to how much you can ask and there is often an extra effort above what you ask that give that feeling like you really matter.

2. Risk of Misdiagnosis or Harmful Advice

AI tools are only as good as their programming. If an app misinterprets a user’s input, it could provide inappropriate or even harmful advice. For example, a person expressing suicidal thoughts might receive generic coping tips instead of being directed to emergency help.

Another case that can create dangerous consequences is when you don’t manage or are not capable to express what is actually going on for you. It is so common in therapy that people struggle to feel and express their emotions. A machine may think that is a sign of no emotion and therefore a lesser gravity of impact of the situation on that individual. Really dangerous considering that the disconnection from feeling can be sign of the exactly the opposite.

3. Privacy and Data Security Concerns

Mental health data is extremely sensitive. Many AI apps collect personal information, and there’s always a risk of data breaches or misuse. Users must carefully review privacy policies to ensure their information is protected.

4. Over-Reliance on Technology

Relying solely on AI for mental health support can prevent individuals from seeking professional help when needed. While AI can be a helpful tool, it is not a replacement for licensed therapists, especially for severe conditions like bipolar disorder or schizophrenia.

5. Limited Scope of Effectiveness

AI is best suited for mild to moderate mental health concerns. It may not be effective for deep-seated trauma, complex psychiatric conditions, or crises requiring immediate intervention. Human therapists can adapt to nuanced situations in ways AI currently cannot.

Conclusion

AI-powered mental health tools offer significant benefits, including accessibility, affordability, and instant support. They can be a valuable resource for managing stress, anxiety, and mild depression. However, they are not without drawbacks—lack of empathy, privacy risks, and limitations in handling severe mental health issues are important considerations.
​
The best approach may be a balanced one: using AI as a supplementary tool while recognizing when professional human intervention is necessary. As AI technology continues to evolve, it has the potential to become an even more effective component of mental health care—but for now, it should be used thoughtfully and in conjunction with traditional support systems when needed.

Author

Lara Briozzo & AI